Ships in the Night
Stuart (2): Welcome back to Ask Dr.
Fish for November, 2000â¦
November?
Is this Oc- November 2026.
We are in November.
Uh, my name is Stuart Carlton, and
things are a little bit weird 'cause
it's a new format for us this month.
We have abandoned the live format,
um, in honor of a, a dead format.
Um, so anyway, uh, welcome back to Ask Dr.
Fish.
My name is Stuart Carlton.
I'm joined today by not
one, but two Doctors Fish.
The first one, Dr.
Fish himself, Titus Seilheimer, fisheries,
uh, specialist with Wisconsin Sea Grant.
Titus, what's up, man?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Good morning.
Uh, just love talking fish, so
Stuart (2): also love talking fish.
As long as you're there, and as long as
we're also joined by Katie O'Reilly, Dr.
Catfish, the one, the only, the special,
uh, who I was at the same conference
as last week but missed somehow.
Hmm.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Like, like ships in the
Stuart (2): Like ships in the
night or like nights in a ship
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
ships in Lake Michigan, uh, floating
through the fog and fortunately missing
Stuart (2): Fortunately
missing each other.
Had it been Lake,
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant: and
Stuart (2): yeah, had it
been Lake Superior, they'd be
writing tunes about us right now
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
I was gonna say no gales in November
Stuart (2): Yep.
We all know her.
We all love her, but not
as much as she loves lakes.
It's Megan the Lake Lover Gunn.
Megan Gunn.
Megan Gunn she/her:
Good morning, everybody.
I'm so excited to be here with you all.
Stuart (2): I know.
Super fun.
It's been a while.
Yeah.
Well, you were at the, you were at the,
uh, State of Lake Michigan, too, right?
Megan Gunn she/her: I was.
Stuart (2): So we're, we're all back.
Well, except for Titus, right?
I did ⦠I also got to see Katie, so- Mm.
You did it right ⦠it was great.
Yep.
Uh, somehow I saw her in
the thing, and then I tryâ¦
And, uh, she was leading
this amazing session.
Mm-hmm.
Uh, uh, packed to the gills.
Um, look, you saw that?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Uh, and then, um, uh, I was like,
"Oh, I must make contact with
Katie O'Reilly after this session,"
and then something else happened.
I did some administrating, and then,
uh, the titular Ship in the Night.
Um, well, it's only titular if we make
the, uh, episode title Ships in the Night.
So Ray, make that happen.
Anyway, here's my point.
Uh, State of Lake Michigan, I
learned all kind of cool stuff.
And so we had this rundown,
and we still have questions.
If you still have questions for our Dr.
Fish, send it to askdrfish@gmail.com,
or I don't know how you
do social media anymore.
Is that still a thing?
Um, if it is, then find them on social
media and, and ask 'em that way.
Uh, but in between now and
then, I've got questions.
And so my first one is this.
So I learned all about these, uh, uh,
this guy, Lars Rudstrom, came and gave a,
a- Mm-hmm ⦠plenary talk, 45 minutes,
and this guy was a classic fish dude.
Um, and so he was cracking me up.
And,
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
He was, you know, Swedish to begin with,
Stuart (2): yeah.
Yes.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
your classic fish dudes, you know,
Stuart (2): Well, I mean, he had
like a orange, uh, like a orange
beanie cap, and I was like, "Of
course you have a orange beanie cap."
He had this photo of him with a orange
beanie cap and like this, uh, a metal
camper's mug of coffee, and I was
like, "You are the most on the boat
guy- ⦠I think I've ever seen."
And then I went on a field
trip with him, and out of his
pocket, guess what he pulled?
Orange beanie cap.
I was like- ⦠"This is amazing.
This is amazing."
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I, so I was at, uh, I was at Cornell for
about a year, and that's where Lars is.
And he-- I remember one time in one
of the meetings, or was it a social?
I don't know.
But Lars, uh, led us in a drinking song,
Stuart (2): Ja
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I wish I rememberâ¦
You know, in Swedish, um, that's just
kind of my classic, uh, Lars moment.
Stuart (2): Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
uh, there's also a sea lamprey story,
which isn't mine, but it is a Lars, uhâ¦
Lars likes to cook sea
lamprey once a year.
Stuart (2): Really?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
a recipe.
Make sure to ask him about
Stuart (2): Yeah, we gotta
get him on the big show.
Um- Yeah, what is that, what does
sea lamprey taste like, though?
Well, the thing is they're tubular
in shape, almost like a hotdog.
No, way too long to be a hotdog.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
It's like a footlong, foot,
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
over on
Stuart (2): It's a Dodger Dog, yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
yeah, footlong, uh, Gobi dogs, um
Stuart (2): So gross
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
years back there was a big, you know,
interest in having sea lamprey from
the Great Lakes be sent over to the
UK for the Queen's Jubilee because
I guess, you know, lamprey p- pie
basically is a big thing over there.
But the concern, at least
here in the Great Lakes, is
that got pretty high mercury,
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
don't wanna have too many
Stuart (2): Well, by the time you're
the queen's age, or the queen's age at
that point, uh, you know, you're not
too worried about Mercury I don't think.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Uh,
Stuart (2): What is it with-
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
did, and they did send themâ¦
The Great Lakes Fishery
Commission sent them over there
Stuart (2): Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
um, they needed for the tradition.
Probably no one ate that lamprey pie, but
Stuart (2): No, but the,
it photoed well, right?
Yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
photo
Stuart (2): I wonder if
somewhere the Britishâ¦
They, they have a very
different conception of pie.
As we approach the
Thanksgiving, uh, season.
Yeah, exactly.
It's got me thinking about pies.
Um, and that's not the kind
of pie we're thinking about.
But that doesn't answer it.
Have either of you had lamprey?
I've never had lamprey.
I bet Thomas has.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
ha- cannot say I've had
Stuart (2): Yeah, okay.
Well, anyway
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
But Lars did bring up a good thing.
You know, he was talking about alewife
and people eating alewife and other
herring, and had, like, pictures of
Stuart (2): Yep.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
shops
Stuart (2): Mm-hmm
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
uh, in Sweden.
So I mean, Stuart, if
the, the Gobi dogs don't
Stuart (2): Could be the alewife thing.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
herring
Stuart (2): Yeah, you could, you,
you knew he was from Sweden when
he started talking about how much
he liked eating alewife, right?
It's just a, it's a very differentâ¦
But it's lower on the food
chain, so it actually might
make a fair amount of sense.
Um, they're always trying to get you.
Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
a native, you know, native alewife on
the coast, like they are much bigger
Stuart (2): Are they?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
big, robust fish compared
to what they are here.
Stuart (2): Huh?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I think they're a lot meatier,
maybe a little moreâ¦
Yeah, they're oily.
They'd probably be good smoked though
Stuart (2): They just look like all
you could do was, like, drop 'em in a
fryer and eat 'em crispy, and you just
have, like, alewife fries all the time.
Alevife fries nonstop.
Anyway, excellent.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Gobi, gobi dog with
Stuart (2): With alewife
fries on the side.
There would be thisâ¦
It's gonna be the smelliest food cart,
like- Mm-hmm ⦠but if you get there,
if you can manage to approach it, yeah.
The other thing is when you see that
picture, and I'm not saying this is Lars,
but you th- you look at how cold it is,
and you have the orange cap, and you got
the camping cup with the coffee in it.
You know you gotta put a little
something extra in that cup, right?
You're, like, four weeks
into your field season.
It's either that or you turn to
cannibalism, or why not both?
Anyway, so we talk about mysid
shrimp, and I, I don't know
anything about these mysid shrimp.
So these are little shrimps.
Um, they get to be about an inch,
uh, I think, if I did the math right.
Uh, he was talking in a number
of millimeters or whatever.
And so why do we care about these mysid,
M-Y-S-I-D, my- I think, and we'll put
a link to that in the show notes maybe.
Uh, so what, whatâ¦
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
shrimp,
Stuart (2): Possums?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah, that's their common name
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Okay.
Are they possum shrimp or opossum shrimp?
Well, that's a-
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Well, that's a I mean,
technically they're opossum
Stuart (2): I've had lots of fights about
whether that O is actually pronounced
or not in recent times, so- With who?
Who are you fighting with on that?
My siblings.
Oh.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
No, it's,
Stuart (2): That just shows your
siblings will fight about anything.
Like in the last month we
were fighting about it.
Anyways.
That makes me feel better as a
parent, 'cause right now we're in
a phase where, um, there's a lot of
debate over things, some of which
are maybe that level of importance.
And so I'm glad to hear that you,
as a relatively well-adjusted
adult- ⦠are still having
those fights with your siblings.
Uh, anyway, mindset shrimp, Katie.
Yeah
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Yeah, so mysid shrimp or the
opossum/possum shrimp are a really
critical part of the Great Lakes food web.
Um, so they do, you know, they're not
plankton because, you know, they have
a little bit more swimming ability.
Maybe they could be considered
plankton, but they're low on the food
chain, and they're a really important
food source, native food source for
a lot of Great Lakes fish species.
However, you know, as Lars alluded
to in his talk, their dynamics have
changed a lot, um, particularly in
the last 30 years as we've had, you
know, zebra and quagga mussels come in.
We've had a lot of other food
web changes in the Great Lakes,
other environmental changes.
And so, um, trying to understand what
has led to the decline of the mysid
shrimp as well as what might be a way
of like, you know, are fish species
doing without this really rich source?
And by rich, I mean, like, it
has a lot of nutrition, has a lot
of fats that switching to maybe
some other kind of lower level
food source of, of zooplankton or
Stuart (2): Right
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
may not provide them
Stuart (2): So even if, even if
they're getting the calorie needs
or whatever, they might not be
getting as much nutrition and that
might change their overall fitness.
Oh, interesting.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah, and this was, you know, like
were, you know, they're kind of,
you know, the native fish or native
fish food that's still there.
Diporeia was the, you know, the little
amphipods that were down on the bottom
that used to be, you know, and that's,
that's probably, you know, quagga
mussels, zebra mussels eat the algae,
so the algae isn't up in the water
column to float down and feed the
Stuart (2): Right
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
But, you know, Mysis can, will
actually move up and down in the
water column, like be dark during
the day really deep and then move up,
uh, closer to the surface at night.
And, um, I, I looked around my
office because in my other, my
other office space, I do have a
Stuart (2): Must be nice
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
uh, of, uh, Mysis that I got when I
was out on the, the chub boat with the
commercial fishermen, and they were, you
know, they were getting bloater chubs, and
their stomachs were just full of Mysis.
So I have, yeah, got this
vial of those that I keep.
I've always meant to look at under the
microscope to confirm they're Mysis.
I mean, they must be.
They're not Hemimysis
because it was too deep.
It was like February, and it
was four hundred feet deep, so
Stuart (2): Nice.
There was a guy from UWM who
talked about Hemimysis at Agler,
now that I think about it.
Um, it was a really interesting
talk actually, um, about something
I don't care about at all, or I
didn't care about, but now I do.
So Hemimysis, that's a different genus.
Are they the same family?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Bloody red shrimp
Stuart (2): Oh.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
The bloody red shrimp, which are an
Stuart (2): Hmm.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
uh, species in the
Stuart (2): Oh
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah, and very different habitats.
Like I probably-- I don't know
who was talking, uh, you know,
if it was John Janssen or who it
Stuart (2): No, no, 'cause
this guy has shoes on
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant: I
mean, they're like in the, like in the,
uh, they're, you know, in the harbors and
the rocks, like Hemimysis closer to shore.
Uh, the shrimp mysis are, you
know, deep water up and down.
So they, they kind of separate out
Stuart (2): Yeah.
They're so cute.
They are so cute.
Here we go.
No, that's not who it was.
I don't know who it was.
It doesn't matter.
All right, uh, excellent.
Well, there we go, mysid shrimp.
And then the other, uhâ¦
So that's cool.
I hadn't heard of them
in a- but it was neat.
They had all these, uh, graphs of, right,
them going through their deal, uh, every
day kind of, uh, cycle of up and down.
And, and Lars had a theory on,
on when they would go down, that
it's, you know, for safety, yes,
but also because they're full.
Um, and you know, when you're,
uh, this is anthropomorphizing,
which of course you should do.
But when you're full, then you just
wanna relax and, you know, uh, maybe-
Mm-hmm ⦠undo the belt a little bit
and, and float your way back down.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Thanksgiving, American Thanksgiving
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant: up,
Stuart (2): Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
kinda what happens.
You
Stuart (2): There it is
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
turkey, and then you sink down to the
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Dark.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
of Lake
Stuart (2): Right.
Yes.
Watching the Lions game.
The other thing we did was
we saw a lamprey barrier.
Um, this was on a field trip.
Like I was saying- Oh, so cool
⦠before we started recording, I
don't normally go on the conference
field trips because I'm an adult.
Um, but, uh, but I went on this one
for, because, um, the mayor of Michigan
City was gonna be on it, and we thought
it was important strategically that I
meet the mayor of Mich- Mayor Angie.
She was great.
Mm-hmm.
Uh, uh, um, it was a fun tour, uh, we
did where we saw a lamprey barrier.
May- Mayor Angie did not see that,
but there's also this park that they,
um ⦠On Trail Creek, which is a, a, a
stream that goes through Michigan City.
It's actually the reason Michigan City
is there at all is because it was,
it was, it was founded on that creek.
And, uh, you know, it's a fairly
impounded creek, and they developed
around there, but they've been doing some
restoration work, um, uh, and made this
really nice urban, uh, park, um, that
you can access from Downtown Michigan
City, and you can kinda get all around
Michigan City just using this park.
And, um, and, uh, so Mayor Angie
was on that, and that was cool,
but before that we went elsewhere
and, and to a, a lamprey barrier.
And so I'd never thought about what
these were, but it's just a dam.
Um, right?
It's kind of a low-head dam.
Mm-hmm.
You see the water rushing over
'cause the lamprey can't jump up it.
And then there's this ⦠Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
short and then a, a li- lip over
top 'cause they can't ⦠Like, they
can crawl, they can climb those with
Stuart (2): Oh.
Can they?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
If, as long as you have that little
overhang, they can't make it over that.
So yeah, a lot of purpose-built lamprey
barriers that, you know, other fish could
jump over that if they were inclined to
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Well, when- I saw a fish try to jump.
It did not make it.
Yeah, the fish did not make it.
Um, but, but it probably
did the second time.
I didn't realize, so they
use their lips, like, Iâ¦
We were just watching this, um,
Spider-Man, uh, one of these
Spider-Verses, the first one, last night.
And, uh, uh, incidentally, like,
I'm not a superhero guy, but those
movies are unbelievably good.
Like, they are just amazing movies.
Um, uh, uh, but, but I didn't realize
they use their little, cute littleâ¦
Actually, their terrifying
little mouths to climb up.
That's, that's nutty.
Yeah.
Okay.
Um, but then on the side, so the way these
work is they have the dam, the lamprey
can't get over it, so that's good, but
they also wanna trap them, um, so that
they don't eat additional fish, I guess.
And so off to the side of the dam
is, like, a low flow area, uh, where
they have a little hole essentially.
Mm-hmm.
And the, uh, the lamprey can
crawl into that little hole,
and in there is a big trap.
Uh, and then they pull the trap up,
and they, they have killed the lamprey.
Or they then kill the lamprey.
Yeah.
Or they use them for- Education purposes
⦠education purposes until the lampreyâ¦
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
also, they'll do a mark recapture to
do population estimates on those too,
Stuart (2): Oh, interesting Really?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
are out there.
Stuart (2): They let them back go?
Huh
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
some of them, they will do that.
I know at Peshtigo in Wisconsin is one
of their, their index sites that they
use for, you know, a lake wide estimate,
and they have these trap locations.
And like when they're trapping
them, that is, uh, that's the
time they're going to spawn.
So you, you know, if you remove them out
of the system and they can't reproduce,
then you're going to, you know, keep
those new lampreys from forming.
And since a female can have up to
a hundred thousand eggs, like a
single female, and if you've ever
opened one up, which of course
I have, they are chock-full.
There is just
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
eggs in there.
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
it's crazy.
Stuart (2): The queen loves
those in, like, her boba tea.
Um- But,
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
just pop.
They pop on your tongue.
Stuart (2): yeah, yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
A nice salty, salty pop
Stuart (2): but, uh, how do you, how do
you mark a lamprey for mark-recapture?
So for those who don't know, the real
dummy version of mark-recapture, and,
and it's more complicated than this,
but basically you, you mark a bunch
of fish, and you let them go off and
You capture a bunch of
fish, and you mark them.
You let them go do their thing for some
period of time, and then you capture
a bunch of fish, and you count what
proportion of those are marked, and you
do some stats to u- you know, to roughly
estimate the, the size of the population.
Uh, how do you mark a,
how do you mark a lamprey?
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
You know, I'm not sure exactly.
I was gonna say probably fin
Stuart (2): OK
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
when they capture it again and they see
it has, you know, fin distinctly clipped
or, you know, in a certain location,
they know it's been and recaptured.
I mean, there's other ways that are
more, like, fancy using things like
PIT tags, but generally I think for the
lamprey it's, um, the traditional fin
Stuart (2): Okay
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
talk about marking fish and tagging fish.
Like that's a whole,
uh, episode in itself.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
yeah
Stuart (2): Yeah, yeah.
No, but- But their, their dorsal
fin is, like, just one long fin.
Do, like, in different locations, do they,
like, we're gonna do it two centimeters,
or we're gonna do it three centimeters
so they know where they're catchâ¦
I guess they're not really swimming that
far from where they're marking them.
But how do, how do they decide
where to do that fin clip?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah, I mean, like it d- you
know, depending on your fish,
like, you know, a regular fish.
Lampreys just have a dorsal
and then a caudal fin,
Stuart (2): Mm-hmm.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
you know, back and tail.
And they-- I wouldâ¦
What do you think?
They just a notch out of it?
Stuart (2): OK
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
it's notâ¦
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
guessing.
It's
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
notch.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
And, and like, you know, for like if
we're, if we're using Trail Creek and
as a, as an example, like there probably
aren't a lot of other streams in the
area that are going to attract lamprey.
So, you know, thereâ¦
I d- I g- that would be an interesting
kind of something to learn more about,
like how far, where do they release them?
Like I, you know, downstream somewhere
Stuart (2): Mm-hmm.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
out in the lake.
I don't know.
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Interesting.
Yeah, they also had a ⦠They
also caught a salmon in there.
Uh, they had a coho and
a chinook I think, right?
Mm-hmm.
And, um, they had marked ⦠Those
were all hatchery salmon, uh,
as I think most are in the Great
Lakes or at least in that area.
But for those they just
cut off ⦠So they have a
Salmon have a adipose fin, right?
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Adipose
Stuart (2): so for those listening,
the dorsal fin is the jaws fin, right?
The one that, um- ⦠and
the caudal fin's the tail.
Sometimes on the top some fish have a
fin in between that's called adipose fin.
An adipose fin.
It's called an adipose fin.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
You got it.
Grammatically
Stuart (2): with
underneath is the anal fin.
Uh, and these anal fins, these
salmon were, uh, uh, producing
milt all over Ben Dickinson's hand.
Poor Ben.
And, um, and, uh, but they had, they
had cut the adipose fins, uh, as a
way of marking them so they could,
um, do the, I think that same idea.
Mm-hmm
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
and they, they do that in the-- Like, they
probably had coded wire tags in the snout,
or they might have had those, and they do
that in a trailer where they actuallyâ¦
It's all automated, and they go through
like a, you know, a-- have all these
tracks, and the fish go in, and they get
Stuart (2): Fascinating to watch
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
there.
yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
it, yeah,
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
'cause I think Wi-Wisconsin stocks,
like, seven hundred and fifty thousand
Chinook per year, and that's just Wiscon-
Stuart (2): Ja
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
millions of fish that
need to be processed every
Stuart (2): Holy smokes
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Yeah, and it's actually a, a
It's like a formal program, like
mass marking throughout the Great
Lakes, and all the, you know,
states work together, jurisdiction.
Uh, there was some movement, obviously
things have changed politically,
but there was some movement with the
last Congress about having a Great
Lakes Mass Marking Act that would,
you know, free up some additional
Stuart (2): Right
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
expand the mass marking.
So because, like, right now they
don't do it for all hatchery fish.
Um-
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
And it's been, you know, GLRI, and GLRI
doesn't wanna fund it, uh, 'cause it's
not really a, you know, not their focus.
But
Stuart (2): Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
go to the Pacific Northwest, they
have like dedicated programs with
funding do this, whereas we've
been piecing it together, yes
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Mm-hmm.
Excellent.
All right, well, speaking of sea lamprey,
well, let's get to our first, uh,
our first story of the week now that
we're 15 or 20 minutes into the show.
Uh, side note, you can take
this out, Ray, but this is good.
This is a better show than our other show.
All right.
Um, sea lamprey populations are in
decline across most of the Great Lakes.
This is wonderful.
So I'm here looking at, um,
the, uh, Manitoulin Expositor.
That is a newspaper name.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
That
Stuart (2): That is a newspaper name.
Thank you.
The, the Manitoulin E- Expositor
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I mean, you're living on an island,
you know, a large island on Lake Huron.
You
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
a cool name for your newspaper
Stuart (2): and then you go
to the website and the, the
headline font is just beautiful.
Mm-hmm.
I don't know what it is, but it's got
this old t- not old-timey, but it's
this, the serif font that looks like
something you would see in print.
This is amazing.
I'm now going to have to read the,
uh, Manitoulin Expositor every week.
So Manitoulin, that-
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
weekly on the largest
freshwater island in the world,"
Stuart (2): There we go.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
their tagline
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
tagline
Stuart (2): So that's Manitoulin Island-
⦠which we all know is located in the
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Lake
Stuart (2): northern Lake Huron.
Uh, like I said, we all know that.
Um-
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I mean, Stuart hasn't
seen a sturgeon before, so
Stuart (2): I've seen
baby sturgeons like this.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
see, he didn't see a Great Lakes
Stuart (2): I did.
That was my first one.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Sturgeon,
Stuart (2): one of those.
It was really cool, and then I wanted
to go out fishing with my so- 'cause
they stock, uh, trout in a, a nearby
lake, nearby the West Lafayette.
So I actually took my kid fishing
yesterday, and he wanted a
bait casting rod, so all right,
fine, here's a bait casting rod.
So I spent the whole time
untangling his bait casting rod.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah.
Stuart (2): Because they, um,
you know, they have a littleâ¦
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
with
Stuart (2): Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
uh, you know, tangle-worthy,
Stuart (2): Yep.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
of fishing
Stuart (2): yeah, yeah.
Well, he went and then got his spinning
rod, and he sat there and fished while
I messed around with his bait casting
rod, which I then brought home, uh,
and we'll, uh, cut the line on tonight.
'Cause this one, look, he didn't mess
around with this, with this bird's nest.
He was like, "I'm doing it, man."
Uh, so anyway.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
dropped his pole on the ground
Stuart (2): Yeah, he saidâ¦
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
to the next
Stuart (2): Right.
It was, it was like, uh,
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
fisherman
Stuart (2): out.
Right.
So he andâ¦
Yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant: of
Stuart (2): Yeah, Dad, yeah.
Good old fishing as a dad, or mom
for that matter, like all you're
doing is messing with people's lines.
You don't, you don't get to wet a line.
He's like, "Why didn't
you bring your rod?"
I mean, I brought it.
I left it in the, the car.
He's like, "Why didn't
you bring your rod?"
And I was like, "You'll see."
You'll see.
Just you wait.
Whatâ¦
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
supporting role
Stuart (2): Yes.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
he, he had bigger fish to
Stuart (2): Ah.
Anyway, sea lamprey populations declined
across most Great Lakes in 2026.
Um, this was released by the Great Lakes
Fishery Commission, the GLFC, who, uh,
bring, um, lampreys to conferences.
Mm-hmm.
And, uh, so the populations are
in decline, which is a good thing.
Uh, why are the populations
in decline, uh, this year
compared to others, uh, Titus?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah, I mean, well, you know, of
course, we have the sea lamprey.
Great Lakes Fishery Commission does
the sea lamp-- you know, manages
the sea lamprey control program.
I would say the most successful-- one
of the most successful invasive species
management programs in the world.
So, you know, why is it down?
Well, uh, because of decades of effort.
Uh, and you know, you've, you
have met a sea lamprey trap.
Traps are part of the control program,
uh, but also, uh, treatment of, uh,
sea lamprey, uh, mostly juveniles, like
killing them with lampricides is another
big part of, of keeping that down.
And, you know, why is this news?
Well, if, you knowâ¦
Did we, did we talk about it?
I don't even remember now.
But, uh, you know, during COVID, they
missed a year of treatment, and numbers
went up, uh, in a lot of places.
Lake Ontario was very, you know,
a very clear signal of a year
of treatment, see a very quick
rebound, um, in lamprey numbers.
Stuart (2): So just one year was enough
to- That's incredible ⦠for the, yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah.
So it has, you know, I think, uh,
and I, you know, kind of looking at
all the lakes, like, and there's--
it-- there's some nuance to this.
It's like, you know, we have kind of
Michigan, Huron have been down and,
you know, are target, and they have
targets for each of the lakes, like
what, what they ha- want to have.
Lake Erie is, is below target.
That's great, but Lake Erie doesn't
have a lot of good lamprey habitat.
It's like the least numbers of lampreys.
and Ontario has had a really good,
you know, decline, uh, because they
really focused on that after, you know,
the, the problem with, with COVID.
And then Lake Superior is kind of a,
you know, is down, but it's also up.
Like, if you look at the last twenty-five
years, it is up, it is above target.
It's kind of a not a great situation.
But, um, yeah.
So, hey, it's, it's kinda working.
Stuart (2): Why are they able to
do so well in Lake Superior, Katie?
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
In Lake Superior, I mean, there is,
or in many places was a good, healthy
population of some of their, uh,
prey, which oftentimes are things like
lake trout, larger predatory fish.
but I think part of it too is ju-
you know, Lake Superior has a lot
of good lamprey spawning habitat.
Um, but it also has a lot of
l- spawning habitat that can be
difficult to access, remote places.
Um, and so, you know, that coupled
with, example, the COVID restrictions,
you know, maybe led to some places in
the, the Superior Basin not getting
that treatment, which we're now seeing.
And, and like Titus said, even one year
of treatment could, you know, quickly
show impacts, but because lampreys spend
their juvenile stages, uh, in the streams,
sometimes for several years, we're
still seeing impacts of that, you know.
What are we now, six years down
Stuart (2): Mm-hmm.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Um, but hopefully, you
know, we're getting to that-
Basically over that hump
Stuart (2): Ja
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
okay, now, you know, since
the treatment's resumed
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah, the wa- I mean, the
water quality is just too good.
Like,
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
It's just
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
the habitat is just too great.
Stuart (2): Too great in Lake Superior.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
a wonderful lake, you'd probably
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
less sea lamprey
Stuart (2): You remember that, uh,
social media account, Lake Superiorâ¦
Is that still a thing?
I don't even know.
Um, it was popular for a while,
uh, partially 'cause of some
political stuff it did, I think.
We interviewed the person.
I won't reveal it, 'cause
some people didn'tâ¦
In fact, um, our dear friend Carolyn
Foley never listened to that episode
because she didn't wanna know-
uh, you know, didn't wanna
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
don't wanna
Stuart (2): peek behind the mask.
I'd forgotten about that
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
salty or, you know, bitter
because I never got as manyâ¦
Like, I was like, "I'm
a real person, and I
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
you know, a tiny fraction of
Stuart (2): But it was a good shtick.
And then the, the oneâ¦
We won't get into it 'cause we don't
need to get into politics, but the one,
um, there was one tweet in particular
that I still remember that really
sent things up into the stratosphere.
Uh, and it was, it was, it was good.
Um, you would not have done it, Titus.
Uh, you would not have sent that
tweet, or maybe you would have.
Um, I don't know.
Maybe
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
mean, it is said that Lake
Superior never gives up its
Stuart (2): There we go.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
you gotta,
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
respect it
Stuart (2): This is interesting with
the lamprey though, because it's, uhâ¦
I'm, I'm looking at actually applying
for some GLFC funding to understand, uh,
risk perceptions related to lampricide.
And one of the issues they're having
is this idea of a, a shifting baseline,
which is, um, you know, people
don't realize that we need to keep
applying lampricide because it's been
relatively controlled for, for so long.
Mm-hmm.
Um, and so, uh, uh, they're worried that
there's gonna be a decrease-- Or I don't
know if they're worried about it or not,
but there's questions about if there's
gonna be a decrease in support over time.
Um-
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Well, that's a really good point,
uh, Stuart, because I, last year,
as part of the American Fisheries
Society, was invited to go to Capitol
Hill in DC and talk with lawmakers,
not about any particular, you
know, cause, but just giving them
information about invasive species.
And we had several congressional
offices ask us, like, you know, "Okay,
the sea lamprey program's been great.
How, you know, things are going
Stuart (2): Hmm.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
When are you guys gonna be done?
Like, when are the sea
lamprey gonna be done?"
And it's just, like, I think there
is that perception that one day we'll
get rid of all the sea lamprey, and
I think there's maybe a bit of a gap.
Like, you know, Iâ¦
When we use the example of COVID
pauses, that you can't really
take your foot off the gas because
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
can bounce back
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I mean, a- and you talk to anglers
who, you know, remember, like,
and they-- because it's been so
successful, like they used to see all,
like marking is one of the metrics.
So when you see a lamprey mark, which
is, you know, sometimes an open wound
Stuart (2): Mm-hmm
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
just had a lamprey, sometimes it's
scarring, um, you know, and that is one
of the other metrics that they track
as, you know, how well are we doing?
Well, we're seeing a lot less marking
on lake trout and other species.
B- and, you know, because, you know,
anglers who are obviously very passionate,
and commercial fishers are very passionate
about their, you know, resource,
they're not seeing it necessarily.
But, you know, and I-I've done a--
I've done like outreach events with
the GLFC before, um, and, you know,
that is-- like they, they have a
really dedicated, outreach program.
I mean, you know, next to Sea Grant,
they're probably doing some of the
most outreach in the Great Lakes region
because, you know, you really need toâ¦
You know, and like you talk to
anglers, and they're like: "Well,
are these a problem anymore?"
And it's like: Well, okay, let
me tell you about, you know, why
you might not be seeing them.
You might not perceive them
as a problem, but, um, yeah.
Uh, soâ¦
And, you know, then start talking and
thinking about things like genetic
control and start r-releasing gene drives
into the Great Lakes and, oh, okay.
Um, let's really mess stuff up.
Stuart (2): Yep.
But it's still, uh, it's still ⦠It's
interesting 'cause our other story
related to this, um, is, uh, that lake
trout harvests, lake trout, excuse
me, harvest has been scaled back,
um, partially because of higher sea
lamprey numbers, right, related to that.
Uh, and so, um, you can see sort of
the direct effects from that COVID.
It's been, it ⦠Like you mentioned, that
you mentioned that on Capitol Hill, Katie.
You can see that direct, uh, that direct
⦠It's sort of in the, a natural experiment.
There we go.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Mm-hmm.
Stuart (2): a natural experiment.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah.
That, and that
Stuart (2): yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
the lake, lake trout is, you know,
that's kind of a specific example for
the Apostle Islands region of Wisconsin.
So, you know, like lake-wide abundance
of lake trout has been like, you
know, it's positive, it's increasing.
You know, two years ago they were
declared fully restored and, you know,
all of a sudden, you know, probably a
big part of this decline is, you know,
just the number of lampreys out there
Stuart (2): Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
you know, feeding on these lake trout.
And, you know, it-- I guess
it's very complicated.
Like management's hard, and that's
why I'm glad we're, we're-- we work
for universities and we get to, uh,
you know, not have to make those hard
Stuart (2): Hard decisions, yeah.
And one of the, I don't know if it
was a article or something that the
Great Lakes Fisheries Commission had
that I read, it said, like, only one
in four fish survive a lamprey attack.
So it's just like, just the numbers of
fish just aren't there for them to be able
to, to catch and harvest and everything.
Yep.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
and even if they do survive, they've
done research that they might
actually have, like, reproduction.
Like, there's costs.
Stuart (2): Mm.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
less successful reproduction
in the future too.
So yeah, it is.
and we were talking about Mysis
before, which leads to, you know,
ciscoette in Lake Superior who are
eating kaya, who are, you know,
migrating in response to Mysis.
And, you know, part of why-- Or they,
you know, one of the assumptions
is that, you know, Lake Superior is
able to support this larger lamprey
population because they might actually
be feeding on ciscoette where we're
not even seeing the predation.
Like, we're not seeing the impacts because
these, you know, fat lake trout are so
deep and not being fished for that, you
know, you get these, you know, kind of
compensatory, uh, effects on, you know,
buffering like the other lake trout.
And now we're seeing, oh, maybe
it's so many lampreys that, you
know, it-- you can't even survive
that, and we're seeing real impacts.
Stuart (2): And with lake trout,
those are native fishes too, right?
The salmon are sometimes, not
controversial among anglers necessarily,
but can be- ⦠uh, controversial
among, um, uh, the general public
sometimes, um, because they're introduced
by Hart Tanner in 1960-whatever.
Uh, but the lake trout are natives,
and so you hate to see that.
Yeah.
All right.
But all this is just, uhâ¦
Look, we got all this.
We're jumping straight to the
most important thing here, which
is, uh, it's sturgeon news.
That's our new, um, that's our new
segment that Megan introduced- Ooh, that's
sturgeon news ⦠uh, several months ago.
And I've, I've, I've, I've got a, uhâ¦
So Logic Pro is the software I
use to, um, make our stupid theme
music, and I've got a Logic Pro
file saved for the sturgeon news.
So, no, we don't have a
sturgeon news song yet.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant: Oh.
Stuart (2): stupid.
No.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I was like, "World premiere
Stuart (2): No, no.
Maybe next month.
Maybe n- it's really exciting, too.
You're gonna be like, "This was,
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
time for
Stuart (2): this was
worth the nine months."
Mm-hmm.
I forgot about Fishmas.
Well, I know what we're
talking about next month.
There's a whole Fishma- oh, my goodness.
Wow.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
See?
Stuart (2): aâ¦
Yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
It's November,
Stuart (2): Oh, yeah.
All right.
Oh, fun.
Uh, but we'llâ¦
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
60 degrees out
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
feel like November,
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Anyway, we'll reintroduce my Fishmas song.
I'd forgotten about that, that, uh, former
editor Sandy Swoboda said she thought
might qualify as workplace harassment.
She wasn't sure.
Um, we'll, we'll bring that one back.
But no, theâ¦
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
editor, uh, Kia
Stuart (2): Well, not because of that.
She is- Because she is busy and- Right.
Right.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
tells
Stuart (2): There's one thing our editors
know, don't make fun of me, right?
That'sâ¦
The whole staff has got
that on, on, on, uh, lock.
Okay.
Uh, enough of that.
But no, this is the point.
We have this, uhâ¦
Well, now I've lost it.
The caseâ¦
There it is.
The case of the dead sturgeon.
So if you go to, uh, Sea Grant,
Wisconsin Sea Grant's website,
which is, uh, seagrant.-
Oh, I love that title
⦠.wisc.edu/dead-sturgeon,
you're gonna seeâ¦
Uh, uh,
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
apex of my career
Stuart (2): yes.
Titus is- This is
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
nothing except, uh, dress up in a costume
Stuart (2): we all know this is Bonnie
Willis's work, or at least in part.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
and Jenna,
Stuart (2): I don't kn-
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant: uh,
Sarah Congdon are, you know, are-- It's,
it really credit to our communications
Stuart (2): Yes.
All right, so- Why don't you
have that on your wall yet?
That should be right behind your head.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I know.
I mean, Iâ¦
Isn't that embarrassing?
Stuart (2): Yo- No
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I was just thinking about that.
I was like, "Should I ask
Bonnie for actual pictures
Stuart (2): Yep.
All right, well- We'll be catching guests
⦠we've gotta tell people what it is.
So, so there's a- Agreed.
⦠a, a story about a dead sturgeon.
But what it, it, they did it up
in this sort of film noir style.
So here's Titus in a trench coat
and- ⦠uh, one of these, uh, hats.
I don't know what the hat is called.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
It's a fedora
Stuart (2): fedora, um, style
hat, and, uh, it's all this
black and white photography.
Um, and he's got- ⦠he's, he's
dressed up like a, he's got one of
these magnifying glasses where it looks
like he's trying to set a ant on fire.
Um, and, uh, it's really
great, uh, this story.
So Titus- It's so good ⦠what
happened exactly here?
Uh, first of all, everybody pause and
go, go read the story, but then give us
the backstory both on what, what this,
what, on the actual sturgeon story,
and then yes, on the process of making
this ridiculous, uh, film noir, uh,
uh, Titus Bogart style, uh, uh, story.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah.
So, I mean, so it wasâ¦
I was down on the beach.
I wa-- It was in the spring.
I was working, uh, doing some beach
tows for, you know, a lake-wide,
uh, larval whitefish project.
So I was just working down on the
beach 'cause, you know, it's fun.
Uh, and, you know, people walk by.
Sometimes they talk to me,
other times they don't.
Um, but these people, a couple walked
by, they, you know, chatted with
me a bit, and then they came back,
and they were like, "Oh, you gotta
see, there's a sturgeon down there."
And I was like, "Uh, okay, sure."
And I was like, "Yeah, it'sâ¦"
And they were like, "You
know, it's this big."
And I was like, "Yeah, it's
probably a common carp."
So then I went down there,
and well, sure enough, it was,
it was a dead lake sturgeon.
It was about four and a half feet long.
and then I was like, "Wow, you
know, this is, you know, a fish
that certainly exists in the lake,
but that you don't see a lot."
So then, you know, I was on the case, uh,
and, uh, you know, I got on the phone.
Well, I-- like I sent an email to the DNR.
I let them know this was there, and
then, talked to my friend Karen Murchie
from Shedd Aquarium, who was coming
the next day actually to set up our,
our spawning, uh, sucker spawning site.
And so she was bringing a PIT tag reader
'cause I was like, you know, they have
these tags go into fish, and I was
like, "Hey, you know, is there aâ¦
You know, is this fish tagged?"
And so she showed up, and
we went down to the beach.
She wanded it with her PIT tag reader.
Sure enough, we had a number.
We sent it to the DNR office in
Milwaukee, um, and they, uh, were
able to kinda track that PIT tag.
It wasâ¦
It had actually been tagged, in 2022.
Uh, so it was a pretty
big fish at that point.
It wasn't one of those little, you know,
Stuart (2): Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
babies that was stocked.
But they've beenâ¦
You know, actually, it probably was one
of those babies, because they've been
stocking those in the Milwaukee River
area for over twenty years, they haven't
been PIT tagging them the whole time.
So it was probably one of those
very early, um, sturgeon that
were stocked as part of that, uh-
Stuart (2): How old, how
old is a four-foot sturgeon,
or four-and-a-half foot?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yeah, I mean, I, it, it
was a pretty big fish.
I don't, I don't know.
Like it could've been, you know,
it was probably 20-plus years.
Stuart (2): Wow
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
It was in kind of bad shape.
Like, I was like, I should have
tried to dig around, you know.
Stuart (2): Yeah, buddy
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
"Could you tell what happened to it?"
And it was like, well, it was, it
was pretty rough at that point.
It had been washing around in the lake.
It was, you know, itâ¦
I was like, I could open this thing up.
I could take this and
put it in my freezer.
Stuart (2): Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I was kind of like, uhâ¦
When we
Stuart (2): do you have a work freezer?
Yeah
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
like I couldn't find the fish anymore.
And so fortunately I had some
sturgeon that I use for education
that I got from, uh, UW Milwaukee,
uh, where they use them in research.
But so I brought one down and like,
Stuart (2): Wait, so that one,
that one with Karen Murchie, is
that the, is that the Sturgeon?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
is the actual sturgeon.
Yeah.
So, that's
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
was really worried that he, you were
unveiling this, like, movie-making
Stuart (2): Oh, I'm
obsessed with that stuff.
When I was a kid, we were, um, we
went, like, fishing with my class, my,
like, fifth grade class or whatever,
and, uh, we didn't catch fish all day.
And, like, a news crew came
out from, like, the local spice
guy- ⦠and they came out toâ¦
I don't even know how they got out there.
Like, probably somebody knew somebody.
And one kid, my friend Gabe Howe,
hey, Gabe, if you're out there, he
finally caught a stupid bluegill.
This was at a city park in New Orleans.
Um, but the camera guys
were off somewhere else.
And so they came running over
and they said, "Throw it back.
Throw it back."
So he had to keep it on
his line and throw it back-
and reel in the line while they filmed it.
And ever since then, no kidding, I've
been obsessed with, like, how theâ¦
So yeah, this is what, that, that's
exactly why I asked that question,
Katie, is 'cause I'm curious.
Well, this is awesome,
Titus, and what a fun, uhâ¦
So did you have to buy a
trench coat and a fedora?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Uh, so it was a borrowed fedora
and one of our comms team found, I
think it was like a fifteen dollar
thrift store, uh, trench coat.
So
Stuart (2): The best thing is how-
But you just have magnifying glasses-
Yeah ⦠because it's science.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Exactly.
Stuart (2): The best
thing about it is how-
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
my office
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Wait.
The best thing about it is how
the fedora basically fits, like
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
was, it was definitely too small
for my giant, like pumpkin-sized
Stuart (2): but that's good.
I like it that it's a little bit s-
no, it's, this is, this is solid work.
This is solid, solid work, so
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
you know, they were like, "Hey,
d- would you wanna do this?"
And I was like, "Uh, y- what?
Dress up in a costume and do stuff?
Of course I'd do
Stuart (2): Right.
All right.
Yeah.
Well, I'm sending thisâ¦
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
you don't have to
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Right.
"Which costume would you like?"
He opens up his, his trench coat- ⦠and
in there is a bunch of costumes.
Joey says.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
You want me to be a fish
taco in a trench coat?
Stuart (2): Yeah, that's right.
I forgot about your fish taco costume.
Uh, we ran into Titus a week or a
couple of weeks ago at an event, and,
uh, he had his fish taco costume on.
It was- Yeah, it was
great ⦠pretty sweet.
Much better than my
baseball player costume.
Did you have a costume?
What was your costume?
I did.
I was a flapper.
A flapper.
1920s flapper.
Oh, yeah.
That was nice.
Yep.
Yeah.
Yeah.
We were at a, a costume party.
That's excellent.
My wife, this can't go in, right?
We were talking about, like, you
know, when you get to be about
13, 14, you get lame costumes.
And, uh, uh, so she remembered,
she's like, "Wait, me and all my
friends at, like, age 14, we all went
to Halloween dressed as flashers."
Oh my gosh.
Wearing, like, trench coats or whatever.
And that reminded me of
two things, or twoâ¦
Well, first of all, thanks, parents.
Like, what are you doing?
And second of all, I
forgot about flashers.
Yeah.
Like, that was, you know, the '80s.
It was a thing.
It was you were gonna get poisoned
candy, and you were gonna get flashed.
Yeah.
Um, or if you're lucky,
you got drug candy.
Uh, like, you know.
Those three options.
Yeah, yeah.
It's poisoned or drug candy, and then
you're gonna get flashed on the way
to getting kidnapped, and that was,
like, the entire, like, '80s and '90s.
Um, every Halloween, it was a nightmare.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
blades
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Mm-hmm.
Oh, yeah, razor blades too
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
I wasn't sure if razor blades
were more of a '90s thing, but
Stuart (2): yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Mm-hmm.
Stuart (2): drugs got expensive, and so
the economy.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
make
Stuart (2): Yeah, yeah, that,
that, that, that inflation
and the ⦠Anyway, excellent.
Well, we normally have a ga-
I don't have a game prepared,
um, so how do we end this, Dr.
Fish?
Megan, how do we end this?
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Can we do our turducken, like
make your own, uh, new turducken,
Stuart (2): you wanna make your ownâ¦
All right, all right, so let's do that.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
turducken
Stuart (2): won't be as- we won't
have as much game scaffolding.
But yeah, so, uh, I forgot,
Megan, um, all by herself, uh,
came up with a bunch of themes.
Uh, and this month's theme- Megan,
would you like to read this theme?
Yes, I'd like to read this theme.
This month's theme is, because it's
Turkey Day is around the corner,
turducken is tired, so let's refresh
this dish with turducken or turwaldo.
Turwaldo.
So you've got turkey, walleye, and perch.
Wait, where's the dough in that?
I don't know.
Listen, this was a long time ago
that I put these things together.
Turwaldo.
So let- Turwalpie ⦠Jason Turwalp.
Anyway,
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Wallerch
Stuart (2): turwalpers.
Or you canâ¦
So I guess what I wanna know is if you had
to put a turducken type of dish together-
Yeah ⦠what would be your dish and why?
Yeah.
So for those who don't know, 'cause this
is a Louisiana thing, um, a turducken,
everybody knows at this point I think.
Mm-hmm.
But it's a turkey that is
stuffed with a duck, and that
duck is stuffed with a chicken.
Turducken, and you fry the whole thing.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
John Madden
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Yeah, made famous by John Madden,
um, the, the, the greatest football
announcer, and it's not even close.
It's, it, you know, he is the, uh, yeah.
Anyway, um, and-
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
John Madden football announcer
Stuart (2): is, he is, he is.
And well, near Wisconsin.
Like, I know he wasn't from
Wisconsin, or I think he wasn't,
but, uh, he, he was very Wisconsin.
Um, they got a John Madden movie coming.
Nicolas Cage playedâ¦
Anyway, uh, and so this
was a, a Cajun thing.
You would getâ¦
And it came from Louisiana and, and
my dad got one once during prime
John Madden turducken, uh, uh, craze.
And, uh, it, it was, it was very
expensive, and, uh, 'cause these
were '90s dollars, and it was, it
was, it was over 100 '90s dollars.
And, um- ⦠and,
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
razor blades don't come
Stuart (2): No, that's right.
That's right.
And it was stuffed with razor blades.
Yeah.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
what's in the
Stuart (2): yeah, yeah.
All right.
So, so let's, let's, uh, let's, um,
take, uh, 30 seconds, uh, and figure out
what's going in your turducken, and then
you have to justify it or explain it.
Um, so we will, uh, give you 30
seconds, which Ray will take out
using the power of, uh, movie magic.
Or you could put in, like, a little song.
Yeah.
Oh, that'd be good.
Do, do, do, do, do.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
mine 'cause I, I
Stuart (2): Oh, you prepared in advance.
That's 'cause you knew
this was your episode.
You were like, "This is
my episode 'cause we'reâ¦
I got my fedora."
All right.
Well, why don't you
start, and we'll give Dr.
Catfish a couple moments.
Titus, Titus Seilheimer,
tell me about your Turwaldo.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Okay, so I decided I wanted to go with,
uh, you know, kind of non-native species.
Stuart (2): Okay
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Katie goes, I will have
a native species one too.
Um, but so mine would beâ¦
So I'm gonna start, I've got a large
bird, I'm gonna go with a mute swan,
Stuart (2): OK
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
outer layer.
Uh, and then I'm going to take
a, uh, I've got a silver carp.
gonna stick that inside the mute
Stuart (2): УгÑ
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
and then I am going to fill that carp
with, uh, Chinese mystery snails.
so that is my, uh, myâ¦
I don't-- it doesn't have a good
name, but, uh, I c- I can't even
Stuart (2): Swan.
What's it?
Well, you got your swan
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Swan carp
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Or
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
snails.
Stuart (2): mystery Squirrel?
A squirrel Squails
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Squirrel squirrels.
Stuart (2): squail A mute, a mute squail
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Mute?
Oh, it's a mute squale.
Stuart (2): I wonder what
happened to the carp in there.
Sorry.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
It's like a flying mute snail.
Um
Stuart (2): So the marketing needs work.
Put money on that Mm-hmm And,
yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
we'll
Stuart (2): mean, the idea
is obviously gold, right?
Yeah, I can envision it.
Yeah.
I'm, uh, I'm, I'm already salivating.
Um, but,
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
I
Stuart (2): yeah, the,
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
can't
Stuart (2): yeah-
Yeah ⦠the marketing maybe.
All right.
Katie, what you got?
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
See, yeah, that was, that was
creative with the non-native angle.
You know, feel like that
should've been my, my
Stuart (2): I mean, one would think
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
I should have passed
that to you ahead of time
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Exactly, just slip thatâ¦
But no, I, you know, I was thinking,
like, how could you most closely
get with the spirit of turducken?
And so, like, the duck obviously would
be something like a mallard, you know,
that we've got in the Great Lakes.
Chicken and, uh, turkey is a little
harder 'cause you're dealing terrestrial.
So I was trying to think, like,
what could be some similar,
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
So you have to catch, you catch a
wild turkey, you throw it in Lake
Michigan, and then you grab it
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
exactly.
Uh, no.
So I was thinking ma- okay,
so we need a bigger thing
Stuart (2): Yeah.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
to be our
Stuart (2): Mm-hmm.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
maybe something like a lake trout.
Then we've got our mallard, so we're
still getting the, the waterfowl.
And then for the chicken, you know,
chicken of the sea typically is tuna,
but what do we have in the Great Lakes?
Eh, maybe something like
a cisco or a whitefish.
Stuart (2): Okay.
There you go.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
to keep it as, as in the
spirit of turducken as
Stuart (2): it.
Love it.
Y'all are making this way too hard.
The answer is you got a
walleye, which you fry.
In there you got a perch, which you fry.
In there you got smelt, which you fry.
And you got your, uh,
your, your, uh, wall pelt.
Good to go.
Wall pelt.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
Fried wall pelt, and then you
have a trip to the emergency
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
Yes.
Stuart (2): Probably so
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
if you really wanna go core
gonads, um, I would say
Stuart (2): Who doesn't?
Yeah.
Okay.
There you go.
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
So
Stuart (2): That's nice
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
perfect existing like sizes would work
Stuart (2): Ja.
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
uhâ¦
Stuart (2): Og det blir
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
then you wash it down
with a chubby Mary, so
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
You wrap it in bacon, um, maybe
you put it in a ciscoette because
that's the fish that fries itself.
Um, and then, uh, I don't know, s-
think it would be good smoked, um,
and then sliced all the way through
Stuart (2): It is.
Well, listener, if you, uh,
try any of these- So disturbing
Diet Cast treats, let us know.
Send us photos
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
We g- this is, you know, our brains
are always, uh, this is just,
Katie O'Reilly Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant:
on
Titus Seilheimer, Wisconsin Sea Grant:
just how it is in here
Stuart (2): Askdrfish@gmail.com.
Ask Dr.
Fish is brought to you by the fine
people at Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant,
Wisconsin Sea Grant, and Gobi Dog Media.
The show is produced and hosted by
me, Stuart Carlton, her, Megan the
Lake Lover Gunn, also her, Doc-
why are we so focused on pronouns?
Uh, Dr.
Fish, Kitty O'Reilly, and Dr.
Fish, Titus Seilheimer himself.
The show is edited by Ray Wallace, and
our podcast artwork is by Ethan Kocak.
You can view his portfolio at
Ethan Kocak, K-O-C-A-K, .com.
There we go.
Uh, if you have questions for
our Doctors Fish, just send
an email, askdrfish@gmail.com.
You can also use the social
media hashtag #askdrfish or call
our hotline at 76-54-96-44-74.
That's 765-496-4474.
Thanks for listening, and, uh, in
between, we'll see you ⦠Mm, let
me do that one again on account of
the fact that we have to change it.
We'll see you the first Monday of
every ⦠Uh, well, we don't re-
when do we release these, Megan?
Uh, we'll have to talk to Ray
about that- Okay ⦠as soon as
we- Hey, we'll see you next month.
We'll see you next month.
We'll see you next month.
And in between now and then, if you have
your fish questions, science questions,
or life questions, maybe culinary que-
actually, maybe not culinary questions.
Maybe save those.
But for the others, ask Dr.
Fish.
All right, excellent.
How do we stop?
I hit stop?